A 48-year-old Jersey City woman who says a New Jersey trooper handcuffed her while she was having a stroke won $11.25 million, and the state is now asking an appeals court to throw out the verdict
New Jersey argues separate pain and emotional distress awards may have resulted in duplicate compensation for Rhines.

What was meant to be a routine morning commute turned into a life-changing medical emergency for a New Jersey woman who was left battling for her life after the very people who were supposed to help her, allegedly mistook her stroke symptoms for signs of intoxication. It was followed by a disastrous delay in medical treatment that left her permanently disabled and needing round-the-clock care. Years later, she was awarded millions in damages by a jury. But the state is now pushing back against that decision, arguing the trooper who made the arrest shouldn’t be legally liable for it.

Drunkenness posing as a medical emergency

According to The Independent, Cheryl Lynn Rhines was driving from her home in Jersey City to her job in Florham Park on October 17, 2017. The 48-year-old is a senior marketing executive for German chemical firm BASF. While driving along the New Jersey Turnpike extension, she suddenly developed signs of a severe stroke.Rhines pulled over near Interstate 78 in Newark as she deteriorated. Her car finally hit a guardrail along the road and kept going.Court documents cited by The Independent say New Jersey State Police troopers arrived about 30 minutes later. They said they found Rhines having trouble communicating and showing clear physical signs such as facial droop, trouble moving and confusion.She said in her lawsuit the stroke impacted the right side of her body, making it difficult for her to follow instructions or control the vehicle. She was also said to be unable to speak properly and only able to give limited answers. Trooper Jennifer Albuja, however, suspected Rhines was under the influence of some unknown substance.

Get handcuffed instead of emergency treatment

According to The Independent, Rhines was taken out of her car, handcuffed and taken into police custody instead of going straight to the hospital.Her attorneys said the trooper did not realize how serious her medical condition was, given numerous visible signs of a stroke. The lawsuit also claimed officers said Rhines was being uncooperative and suggested she was purposely making things difficult.The Independent reported that Rhines allegedly struggled to keep herself under control as she was thrown onto the hood of her car. Her lawyers also said she had bruises on her arms, knee and shin that were noted when she was finally given medical treatment.Instead of being taken to a nearby emergency stroke center, Rhines ended up at the New Jersey State Police barracks in Somerville. Emergency medical personnel were only called when someone at the station saw her condition.The delay cost Rhines about two and a half crucial hours where she might have had urgent stroke treatment, The Independent reported.

Late treatment leading to permanent disability

The results of the delay in medical care were catastrophic, the report says. Medical professionals were eventually able to break up the blood clot in Rhines’ brain, but the damage had already been done.The Independent said the delay caused “substantial brain injury” and “permanent disability.” Rhines was left with constant difficulties of communication and was unable to continue with her professional career, needing ongoing assistance with daily tasks.In her lawsuit, she contended the officers should have realized she needed immediate medical attention and called for emergency services instead of treating her condition as a possible criminal matter.The case also raised wider issues about police training, emergency response procedures and the duty of officers when confronted with people showing signs of serious medical conditions.

Jury awards $11 million-plus in damages

The lawsuit ultimately resulted in a huge monetary award. NJ reports that an Essex County jury awarded damages of about $19.1 million in January 2025.But the jury also determined that some of Rhines’ injuries were caused by the delay in treatment, reducing the award to about $11.46 million. Further adjustments brought the final judgment to approximately $11.25 million.Superior Court Judge Thomas Vena denied the state’s request for a new trial in April 2025, allowing the judgment to stand.

Verdict appeals New Jersey

The state is now trying to overturn the judgment before a three-judge panel of the Appellate Division in Trenton. New Jersey filed its appeal in October 2025, stating that Albuja had acted in good faith because Rhines’ slurred speech, disorientation and inability to stand reasonably suggested possible intoxication, NJ report said.The state says the trooper should be immune from prosecution for her actions. Or it has asked for a new trial or a reduction in the damages awarded.Another important point is the jury instructions and the calculation of damages. The state argues that awarding separate damages for pain and suffering and emotional distress could have resulted in Rhines being compensated twice for overlapping injuries.Her attorneys have disputed that position, saying the emotional trauma of being restrained and allegedly denied medical aid was separate from the lasting effects of her brain injury.According to NJ, Rhines’ attorneys also argue that the trooper had a duty to call for medical assistance before making an arrest, especially since the woman showed signs of having a stroke.Now it is up to the appeals court to decide whether to uphold the original finding of liability and the award of damages. To Rhines, the legal battle is just another chapter in a tragedy that began on a routine morning commute and changed the course of her life forever.Image Courtesy: Google Gemini

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *